Choosing a selling agent: what to compare

Key takeaways
- Meet more than one agent and ask each the same questions.
- Ask for the evidence behind a suggested price, not just the number.
- Compare the marketing plan, the fees and what is included, in writing.
- Pay attention to how each agent communicates; you will rely on it for weeks.
On this page
Choosing who will sell your home is one of the bigger decisions in the process, and it is easy to make it for the wrong reason. Agents often meet several sellers who are comparing them, and the temptation is to choose whoever suggests the highest price. A better approach is to compare how each agent reasons, what they plan to do, what it will cost, and how they communicate.
Meet more than one
Invite two or three agents who are active in your area to look at the home. Ask each the same set of questions, so the answers are easy to compare afterwards. Take notes during each meeting rather than relying on memory, and ask for anything important to be sent to you in writing.
Ask for the evidence behind the price
A suggested price is only as useful as the reasoning behind it. Ask each agent which recent sales they are comparing your home with, and why. Good comparisons are similar in size, condition and location, and sold recently. An agent who can explain the differences between your home and each comparison, in both directions, is giving you more useful information than one who simply names a figure.
Be cautious about a price that is far above the others without a clear explanation. An optimistic figure can win the listing and then lead to a long campaign and pressure to reduce later.
Compare the plan
- Method of sale: what each agent recommends and why it suits this property.
- Marketing: where the listing will appear, what photography and floor plans are included, and whether there are extra costs.
- Timing: when they suggest listing, how long they expect the campaign to run, and what happens if it takes longer.
- Preparation: what they suggest doing before photos and inspections, and what they think can be skipped.
Understand the fees and the agreement
Ask each agent to set out their fees and any marketing costs in writing, including what is payable if the home does not sell. Read the agency agreement carefully before signing, paying attention to how long it lasts, how it can be ended, and what you are committing to. If any part of it is unclear, ask for an explanation in writing, and consider asking a qualified local professional to review it.
Notice how they communicate
Over a campaign you will rely on your agent for updates, feedback from buyers and advice on offers. During the first meeting, notice whether they listen to your questions, whether they answer directly, and whether they return calls and messages when they say they will. Ask how often they will report back and in what form.
Things worth a second look
A few patterns are worth noticing during the first meetings. Pressure to sign an agreement on the spot leaves no time to compare. A suggested price that rises when you mention another agent says more about winning the listing than about the market. Vague answers about fees, or reluctance to put them in writing, make it hard to know what you are agreeing to. None of these settles the decision on its own, but each is a reason to ask more questions before you commit.
Making the decision
Lay your notes side by side: the evidence behind each price, the plan, the total cost and your sense of how well you could work together. The right choice is often the agent whose reasoning you understood best, rather than the one with the most impressive number.
Frequently asked questions
Should I choose the agent who suggests the highest price?
Not on that basis alone. Ask each agent for the recent comparable sales behind their figure. A well-explained, realistic price is usually more useful than a high one that is hard to justify.
What should I ask an agent at the first meeting?
Ask which recent sales they are comparing your home with, what method of sale and marketing they recommend, what the total fees and costs are, how long the agreement runs, and how often they will report back.
Can I negotiate an agent's fees?
Fees and inclusions can often be discussed. Whatever is agreed, make sure it is written in the agency agreement before you sign.
General information, not professional advice. Rules and practice differ by place and change over time: check the details of your own situation with a qualified professional.